BOLI · Bank-Owned Life Insurance

Your BOLI was a good decision. Is it still a good policy?

Many banks bought bank-owned life insurance years ago and haven't compared it to the market since. An independent benchmark shows how your policies stack up against what's available today, so your team can decide with real numbers.

Independent review · No change of agent required · Works alongside your CFO and auditors

What BOLI is

Bank-owned life insurance, or BOLI, is permanent life insurance a bank buys on a group of its officers or employees, with their consent. The bank pays the premium, owns the policy and is the beneficiary.

Banks use it because the cash value grows tax-deferred and the death benefit is generally income tax-free when the notice and consent rules are followed. That growth helps offset the rising cost of employee benefits, like health care and retirement plans.

Company-owned life insurance, or COLI, works the same way for businesses that aren't banks.

Why older BOLI deserves a second look

BOLI is often a small line on a big balance sheet, so it can go years without a real review.

Crediting rates drift

The rate your policies earn can fall well behind what newer products pay, and it rarely gets flagged on its own.

Older product designs

Policies bought 10 or 20 years ago were built with the options of that time. The market has changed.

Annual reviews aren't benchmarks

An internal review or one from the agent who sold it usually checks the policy against itself, not against the market.

Regulators expect it

Bank regulators expect ongoing review of BOLI risk, performance and concentration, not a buy-and-forget asset.

How a benchmark works

A short process built around your CFO's time.

01

A short intro call.

About 20 minutes to understand what you hold and what you'd want to learn.

02

We gather the policy details.

No change of agent of record is needed to run the review.

03

An independent comparison.

A team with decades of BOLI experience measures your policies against what's available in today's market.

04

You see the results.

Where your BOLI stands, where there may be room to improve, and what any change would involve. Then your team decides.

What a BOLI benchmark looks at

An annual review checks a policy against its own history. A benchmark checks it against the market, in four places.

Crediting rates

What your policies earn now, set next to what comparable products in the market are crediting.

Carrier strength

The financial strength of each insurance company you hold, and how much of your BOLI sits with any one carrier.

Product design

How each policy is built: general account, separate account or hybrid, and the features and options that come with it.

Fees

The costs inside the policy, to the extent the carrier discloses them, compared with what is typical today.

Who offers an independent BOLI benchmark

Ten Point Financial Group offers independent BOLI benchmark reviews for community banks and larger banks across the country. The comparison is run by a team with decades of BOLI experience.

It is not a sales pitch for a new policy, and it does not commit your bank to anything. No change of agent of record is needed. You walk away with an independent record of where your BOLI stands, which is useful for your board, your auditors and your examiners.

Read: What is a BOLI benchmark?

How much BOLI a bank can hold

Regulators do not set one fixed dollar limit. In December 2004 the OCC, the Federal Reserve, the FDIC and the Office of Thrift Supervision issued the Interagency Statement on the Purchase and Risk Management of Life Insurance. It still guides how examiners look at BOLI today.

The statement says it is generally not prudent for a bank to hold BOLI with a total cash surrender value above 25 percent of its capital. For most banks, that capital figure is Tier 1 capital plus the allowance for loan and lease losses. It is a guideline, not a hard cap. A bank that plans to go above it, or above its own lower limit, is expected to get board approval first and to justify the decision.

Your percentage can also move without a new purchase. Cash value grows each year, and capital moves with earnings, dividends, growth and acquisitions. A bank that bought BOLI at 15 percent of capital years ago may be at a very different level now. Your bank's actual limit is set by your board, within your regulator's expectations.

Read: How much BOLI can a bank hold?

What regulators expect from a bank that holds BOLI

The 2004 Interagency Statement treats BOLI as an asset to manage, not one to buy and forget.

Board oversight

The board understands why the bank holds BOLI, approves the limits, and sees regular reports on how the policies are doing.

A pre-purchase analysis

Before buying, the bank documents the purpose, the amount of insurance it needs, the product's risks and rewards, and how it fits the bank's capital and liquidity.

Carrier credit review

The cash value is a claim on the insurance company. The bank tracks each carrier's financial strength and keeps its exposure to any one carrier within limits.

Ongoing monitoring

BOLI is meant to be held long term, and getting cash out early can be costly. The bank checks that its holdings still make sense next to its capital and liquidity needs.

If a change makes sense

Some banks find their current policies are doing fine. That's a good outcome too.

When there is room to improve, existing policies can often move into newer ones through a 1035 exchange, a section of the tax code that lets one life insurance policy be exchanged for another without triggering tax on the gain. Any move is reviewed with your CFO, your auditors and your regulators' expectations in mind.

What to weigh before a 1035 exchange

An exchange touches tax, accounting and regulation at the same time, so these come first.

Surrender charges

Some older policies still carry surrender charges, and a 1035 exchange does not erase them. Know what the old carrier will actually release before you compare.

New underwriting

The new policy is a new contract. Expect a new contestability period and some form of underwriting on the insured employees.

MEC status

A policy that is a modified endowment contract stays one after an exchange, and a new policy can become one if it is funded too fast. That changes how withdrawals and loans are taxed, so confirm it on both sides.

Board approval

Most banks take an exchange to the board or the right board committee, with the analysis and the reasons for the change on record. The new policy goes through the same review as any new BOLI purchase.

Who should review an exchange

Your CFO, your auditors, your legal counsel and your CPA or tax professional, before anything is signed. They can confirm how the exchange is reported, how it affects the balance sheet, and how the notice and consent rules apply to the new policy.

Not every review ends in an exchange. Sometimes the best answer is to keep what you have.

Read: Can you do a 1035 exchange on BOLI?

Get the BOLI Benchmark Checklist

10 questions every bank should be able to answer about its BOLI.

Common questions

What is BOLI?+

Bank-owned life insurance is permanent life insurance a bank buys on its officers or employees, with their consent. The bank owns the policy, pays the premium and is the beneficiary. Banks use it to help offset the cost of employee benefits.

Is BOLI taxable?+

Cash value growth is generally tax-deferred, and the death benefit is generally income tax-free when the insurance notice and consent rules are met. Surrendering a policy can create taxable income, which is why changes are usually done through a 1035 exchange.

How much BOLI can a bank hold?+

Bank regulators expect a bank to keep its BOLI within prudent concentration limits relative to its capital, and to review it on an ongoing basis. Your exact limit depends on your bank, so it's part of every review.

What is a BOLI benchmark?+

A benchmark compares your existing policies against what's available in today's market, including crediting rates and product design. It's different from an annual review, which usually checks a policy against its own history.

Do we have to change agents to get a review?+

No. The review doesn't require a change of agent of record. You get the results and decide what, if anything, to do next.

What's the difference between BOLI and COLI?+

They work the same way. BOLI is owned by a bank, and COLI is owned by a company that isn't a bank.

Who offers independent BOLI benchmarking reviews for banks?+

Ten Point Financial Group offers independent BOLI benchmark reviews for banks across the country. A team with decades of BOLI experience compares your existing policies against today's market. No change of agent of record is needed, and your bank decides what to do with the results.

What does a BOLI benchmark look at?+

Crediting rates, the financial strength of each carrier, product design, and fees where the carrier discloses them. Each is compared with what is available in today's market.

Is 25 percent of capital a legal cap on BOLI?+

No. It is the general guideline in the 2004 Interagency Statement. The regulators said holding BOLI above 25 percent of capital is generally not prudent, and that a bank planning to go above it should get prior board approval and be ready to justify it. Many banks set their own limit lower.

Can a bank do a 1035 exchange on BOLI?+

Yes. Section 1035 of the tax code lets a bank exchange one life insurance policy for another without recognizing the gain, as long as the owner and the insured stay the same and the cash value moves directly from the old carrier to the new one.

What if the benchmark shows our BOLI is doing fine?+

That is a good outcome. You will have an independent record that your BOLI is competitive, which is useful for your board, your auditors and your examiners.

Keep learning

How much BOLI can a bank hold?BOLI vs. COLI: what's the difference?What is a BOLI benchmark?Can you do a 1035 exchange on BOLI?COLI for companies that aren't banksHow banks use cash value life insuranceLife insurance for business ownersBusiness tax strategy

Find out where your BOLI stands.

A short call, an independent comparison, and a clear answer. If your policies are doing well, you'll know that too.

Educational content only. Not financial, legal, or tax advice. All services are provided by licensed professionals. Coverage decisions depend on individual circumstances.

Book a Call